From The Chicago Tribune: The Hinsdale Township High School District 86 board is supporting a
decision by the superintendent to deny an objection from a parent who
wanted to keep R-rated films from being shown in a film as literature
class at Hinsdale South High School.
The board voted 4-2 Monday to support the denial. Board members Dianne Barrett and Richard Skoda voted against upholding it.
Parent
Victor Casini of Burr Ridge filed an objection last month with the
district seeking to stop the showing of portions of the films "Brokeback
Mountain" and "American Beauty" in the class in which his 17-year-old
son is enrolled. Although the district allows students who object to
certain materials to do alternate assignments, Casini complained that
would lead to students feeling isolated, judged and deprived of an
educational experience.
In order for Superintendent Nick Wahl to make a decision on Casini's
objection, the district hired an independent consultant to look at
school policies and prepare a report on it.
But Skoda said Monday
not all school policies were considered in the 57-page report. He sought
to have the district continue to look into whether showing the R-rated
movies in-class violates school policies and wether they are age
inappropriate for high school students. Other board members did not feel
that more consideration was warranted.
Trustee Kay Gallo said the
district requires parental permission for students to view the movies
in class, and believes it's the parents' responsibility to decide
whether their children should see the films. She also noted the class is
elective. http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/suburbs/hinsdale/ct-tl-hinsdale-d86-appeal-ruling-20121025,0,4598681.story
According to the Motion Picture Association of America: R — Restricted. Children Under 17 Require Accompanying Parent or Adult Guardian. An R-rated motion picture, in the view of the Rating Board, contains some adult material. http://www.mpaa.org/ratings/what-each-rating-means
I'm pretty sure that parents of kids at Hinsdale will not be forced to bring their parents to attend the class in which R rated movies are being seen.
Further, what possible education value does "Brokeback Mountain" and "American Beauty" possibly have that a PG movie doesn't offer?
This is a horrible decision by the Hinsdale Township High School District. R rated movies have no place in the education curriculum, even if the class is an elective and if they allow these kind of movies in the classroom, it makes me wonder what else they allow in the school.
No wonder home schooling is getting more popular.
(And for those wondering, R rated movies are not allowed in CCSD classrooms and in fact, even PG-13 movies may not be allowed either)
No comments:
Post a Comment