From the San Francisco Chronicle: Mental
health professionals in California would be barred from practicing
therapy to attempt to change the sexual orientation of minors under a
bill that passed the Senate Thursday afternoon and whose fate now rests
with Gov. Jerry Brown
The
first-of-its-kind bill, SB1172 by Sen. Ted Lieu, D-Torrance (Los
Angeles County), bars the so-called “reparative therapy” for a person
under 18 years old, even if that person’s parent or guardian consents to
or asks for it.
Lieu and other Democrats who supported the measure called the
therapy, which is supported by backers of the “ex-gay” movement, “child
abuse.”
“These attempts are quackery and this kind of psychological abuse of children must stop,” Lieu said.
The bill had previously been heard by the Senate, so there was little
debate, but it evoked impassioned speeches by both supporters and
opponents in the Assembly earlier in the week. Republicans opposed the
measure, saying it was an affront to a parent’s ability to decide what
is best for his or her child.
Reparative therapy has been shown to have either no effect or is
linked to negative impacts like depression in those who have undergone
it, according to various studies on the practice. http://blog.sfgate.com/nov05election/2012/08/30/legislature-sends-ex-gay-therapy-ban-to-gov-brown/
To be honest, I don't know if this kind of therapy works or not- I'm sure both sides of the issue have their strong views, just like this writer of this article who clearly shows his bias.
However, I have a problem with lawmakers deciding which therapies should be law and which ones should be criminalized. I think there are many therapies in psychotherapy that are frauds, but it is not my place nor the place of lawmakers to decide if these therapies should be outlawed.
My guess is that this bill, if fought in Federal courts, will be found to be unconstitutional since it will be found to a violation of freedom of speech.
I'm just glad California has solved all of it's budget and pension problems, it's unemployment problems, it's poverty and foreclosure problems and it's crime problem.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Find a therapist in Utah by The Counseling Center! We provide online depression therapy, physical therapy along with many others as per clients’ specific needs & requirement.
ReplyDeletePsychotherapy aims to increase the individual's sense of his/her own well-being. Psychology Academy helps us encourage to develop our full potential.
ReplyDeletepsychotherapy training